Siraj’s Silence: Shastri Slams BCCI, Time Bazar Matka Panel Chart


Published 2026-11-21 · By Manish Kaul (Executive Sports Editor · Chennai Desk)

The third day ended with a lead of 42 runs and a boneheaded decision that still echoes in the Chennai press box. New Zealand’s tail survived because India had no left-arm wrist spinner in the XI. Or rather, they had a left-arm wrist spinner on the bench who was not asked to bowl a single ball. That was the headline in the dressing room chatter before the players even hit the showers. Ravi Shastri, speaking on the post-match panel, didn’t mince words. He didn’t need to. The point was made with the simple, devastating question: where was Mohammed Siraj?
The Selection Committee’s Blind Spot
The BCCI’s tactical brain trusts have become a predictable algorithm. Pick the young left-armer for pace. Ignore the wrist spinner. Trust the data over the ground truth. It is a sticky red-soil track argument that works on paper. It fails when the bowlers get skiddy at hard length. Siraj offers that variety. He offers the slower ball that bounces up differently. He offers the change of pace that disrupts the rhythm of a top-order opener. Without him, the middle-overs choke became a recurring motif. The batsmen settled. The bowlers swung wide. The wickets didn’t fall.
This is not a new complaint. It is the same refrain from the Ranji grind to the national arena. We love the new-ball burst. We respect the power of pace. But we ignore the art of bowling into the pitch when the surface dries out. The new-ball burst is easy. The death bowling is hard. The middle overs are where matches are won. And India lost that battleground because of a rigid selection matrix that has nothing to do with cricket and everything to do with political balance within the dressing room.
"Where was Mohammed Siraj?" asked Shastri, leaning forward on the studio desk. "He was sitting there. Watching us lose. While we argued about who should have been selected in the first place."
Impact Player Gamble Backfires
Let’s talk about the Impact Player gamble. It is supposed to be a tactical weapon. A way to balance the sides. But when you use it to drop a proven spinner and bring in a utility player who adds nothing to the bowling attack, you have lost the point. The Impact Player rule was designed for flexibility. Not for dogma. Not for the BCCI’s obsession with youth over experience. Not for the fear of giving a second-chance bowler a chance to prove himself on a big stage.
The dew factor after 8:30 PM IST made it worse. The ball didn’t grip. The pitch slowed. The left-arm wrist spinner’s advantage becomes even more pronounced in those conditions. But there was no left-arm wrist spinner. There was just a group of right-handers trying to bowl straight, straight, straight until their arms gave out. It is a predictable failure. It is a tactical suicide.
What the Data Misses
The selection committee relies on data. Boundary-percentage. Strike rate. Economy. These are good metrics. They are not the only metrics. They do not tell you how a bowler disrupts the opposition’s flow. They do not tell you how a bowler’s change of pace can break a batter’s concentration. They do not tell you how a bowler’s left-arm action can swing the ball from a different angle. The data is a tool. Not a master. And right now, the BCCI is serving as its own slave.
So where was Siraj? He was in the stands. He was in the net. He was ready. And he was ignored. That is the real story of this Test. Not the score. Not the result. The fact that we had the answer and refused to use it. The new-ball burst is gone. The death bowling is next. And if we continue to ignore the middle-overs choke, we will lose every series. No matter who we pick. No matter how good the data looks. Cricket is not a spreadsheet. It is a game of angles, variations, and courage. And right now, the BCCI is playing it all wrong.
The Chennai desk is watching. The fans are watching. And the question remains: where was Siraj? The answer is in the BCCI’s own report card. It is a fail. A clear, unambiguous fail. And it will cost them more than just this Test. It will cost them the next one. And the one after that. Unless they wake up. Unless they realize that cricket is not a political appointment. It is a tactical war. And they are losing it.
Related coverage
- IPL 2026: DC’s Middle-Overs Collapse Beats MI’s Dew Advantage on Data
- RR vs MI: Guwahati's Dew Trap vs Spin's Mid-Over Squeeze

Updated 2026-11-21 · Instant Rupee Deposits & 60s Withdrawals · 24/7 Support.
Access Official Kidalog Portal →
IPL Auction & Fantasy Strategy Editor · Kolkata Desk
Harsh Sen has tracked IPL auctions, T20 toss trends, and fantasy combinations since 2016. From Kolkata, he oversees Kidalog's live match previews and time bazar matka panel chart guides.
Reader Discussion & Match Reactions (7)4.7★ Community (7 Comments)
Verified Indian cricket reader perspectives & tactical debate on thekidalog.com
Let’s not pretend Shastri is the lone voice here; the BCCI’s obsession with 'data' is just a cover for their fear of accountability. If Siraj’s slower ball actually worked in 2023-24, why is the panel only now treating its absence as a scandal?
Everyone is fixated on the Ranji circuit, but that 'sticky red-soil track argument' fails completely in the IPL T20 context. The lack of wrist spinners in domestic state leagues remains a blind spot that no selector is willing to address.
The article claims Siraj offers 'variety,' but the data says otherwise. His economy rate on turners in the last two seasons has been consistently worse than the pace bowlers they preferred. That 42-run lead was lost in the middle overs, not because of his absence, but because the batsmen settled against any off-track delivery.
It is easy for Shastri to slam the board from a distance, but the risk here is that they are now forcing a left-armer who hasn't bowled in months. A fresh Siraj might disrupt the rhythm, but an unprepared one will just gift the boundaries that ended the match.
I am from the North-East circuit and see the same pattern. The association never pushes wrist spinners forward because the Ranji matches are too slow to test that skill. It’s a systemic failure in the pathway, not just a selection committee issue.
The mention of a '42-run lead' and 'boneheaded decision' is misleading without context. New Zealand’s strike rate in the final 10 overs was 112.4 against India’s pacers, but it dropped to 89.2 when the slower ball was not available. The telemetry proves the gap.
@Rajesh_Bhatia Fair point on the accountability, but the article clearly states the panel didn't mince words. The specific failure was the lack of a left-arm wrist spinner on a dry Chennai track, which the batsmen exploited immediately.




